Edwards, Esther Ritchie
Biography
Esther Ritchie Edwards’ life was punctuated with challenges and ended in tragedy. She was the eighth of twelve children born to Nelson Holder and Annie Cowan Russell Ritchie, and the last child born in Great Bend, Kansas, before the family moved to Utah. Esther, in fact, was only fifteen months old when the Ritchie family relocated to Salt Lake City, in September 1892. It was a religious pilgrimage of sorts that brought them to Utah. Her mother and oldest siblings had converted to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in Kansas and her father did the same shortly after arriving in Utah. They moved west to gather with fellow Latter-day Saints as well as to seek economic opportunity following a series of financial setbacks in Kansas.[1]
There was nothing out of the ordinary about the family’s conversion and relocation except for the fact that Esther’s father, Nelson, was a formerly enslaved man of mixed racial ancestry and Civil War veteran, while her mother, Annie, was white. The family arrived in Utah at the same time that leaders of their new faith entrenched around a racial ideology that prevented people of Black African ancestry from priesthood ordination and temple admission. As a result, Esther’s parents were denied temple access in 1909, after the leader of their congregation concluded that Nelson “had negro blood in him.”[2] Esther, in contrast, passed as white and entered the Salt Lake Temple in 1929.[3] There she received the highest rituals of her faith, the same rituals denied her parents twenty years earlier.
Esther was born on 27 June 1891, in Great Bend, Kansas where her mother and father operated a hotel and livery stable. Latter-day Saint missionaries took room and board at the hotel and soon befriended the family. On September 13, 1891, Willard Richard Johnson and his companion William C. Mann, two of those missionaries, blessed Esther and her two older siblings, Elizabeth and Blanch, at a church conference in St. John, Kansas.[4] Just two days later, the same missionaries baptized the two oldest children in the family, Olive and James Alvie, also at St. John. Their mother Annie had already accepted baptism into the faith one year earlier.[5]
A fire at the hotel and other financial setbacks prompted the Ritchie family to look for economic opportunities elsewhere. The conversion of Annie and her oldest children to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, meant that the Ritchie family had new connections in Utah. William C. Mann, one of the missionaries who had shared the Latter-day Saint gospel with them, had returned to Utah and likely helped to facilitate the family’s move. By September 1892, the Great Bend Tribune noted that the Ritchie family had “left the city and gone to Utah.”[6] Esther was just over one year old when the family relocated.
After arriving in Utah, in November 1892, Mann baptized Esther’s father, Nelson, for the first time, and rebaptized her mother and oldest siblings.[7] The family moved frequently after that. Esther’s father struggled to establish the family economically but they remained committed to their new faith. When Esther’s older siblings reached eight years of age, the earliest age at which Latter-day Saints baptize, they each received the ritual. This was true for Esther as well. The family lived in the Salt Lake 17th Ward when Esther turned eight and it was in that congregation that a man named Charles M. Morris baptized her on September 29, 1899. The following day another man from her congregation, John S. Colbert, confirmed her a member of the Church.[8] Esther remained a Latter-day Saint for the rest of her life.
Little of note survives regarding Esther’s youth other than a singular incident that took place just over a week before her baptism. On 18 September 1899, Esther walked less than a block from her home to the Lowell elementary school nearby. When she arrived, however, her teachers informed her that she did not have class that day until the afternoon and promptly sent her back home, “never doubting that she would find it.” What happened next remains a mystery, other than Esther left the school around 9 a.m. and was not found again until 8:30 that evening. She was miles away from her home in the suburb of Murray. The Ritchies had just moved to the neighborhood so Esther must have gotten turned around as she headed home and somehow wandered all the way to Murray. Her parents frantically looked for her throughout the day and notified the police who joined the search. That evening a telephone message came from Murray that Esther had been found. She was sent home on the ten o’clock streetcar after what must have been an exhausting and nerve-wracking day for the entire Ritchie family, but especially for Esther.[9]
Esther and her family moved four times over the next decade before they finally settled at the mouth of Parley’s Canyon, a major entryway into the Salt Lake Valley from the East.[10] In 1909, her parents were denied temple access because of her father’s race. Her two older sisters, Bessie and Olive, had already been married, or “sealed” in Latter-day Saint parlance, to their spouses in the Salt Lake Temple, but Esther’s bishop nonetheless denied her parents the same privilege.[11]
At some point Esther met Orson S. Edwards, a Latter-day Saint who lived in the Sugar House area of the Salt Lake Valley. Orson was thirty years old and Esther was almost twenty-five when a Latter-day Saint elder married them in Salt Lake City, on 6 April 1916.[12] Just over three months later Esther gave birth to a baby girl, Florence May Edwards.[13] It was the new couple’s only child together. Orson died less than three years later, in January 1919, of the flu pandemic then circling the globe. Orson was one of nearly three thousand people to die of the disease in Utah. His death left Esther a young widow with a two-and-a-half-year-old daughter to raise on her own.[14]
Esther and her toddler Florence moved in with her mother Annie in Salt Lake City, while Esther tried to reestablish herself. She found work sorting laundry and Annie no doubt helped to raise her granddaughter.[15] By January 1921, Esther and Florence had found a place of their own. They appear together that month on a Latter-day Saint census taken in the Burton Ward in the Salt Lake Granite Stake. Esther is listed as a widow on the Latter-day Saint census and the clerk who created the record simply wrote “deceased” in the blank that asked for her husband’s name.[16]
Esther must have been dating by the time she moved into the Burton Ward. She gave birth again on 25 August 1921, this time to a boy she named Nelson Edwards after her father, Nelson Holder Ritchie. Esther was not married at the time. She gave her new son her own last name, Edwards, and not the last name of his biological father. On Nelson’s birth certificate, Esther listed her baby’s father as a man by the name of William White. When the two met, White had been a soldier in Company L, stationed at Fort Douglas on the bench overlooking the Salt Lake Valley. Esther believed that William lived in Kentucky by the time that Nelson was born, likely transferred there by the military. She did not know William’s birthplace and guessed that he was 37 years old at his last birthday.[17] There is no indication that Willaim White ever had contact with his son and may not have known that Esther had given birth. It is possible that Nelson did not know his father’s identity unless he happened to acquire a copy of his birth certificate. He may have grown up believing that his father was Orson Edwards who had passed away two-and-a-half-years before he was born.
The other curiosity on Nelson’s birth certificate is the “color” designation it assigns to Esther. Esther’s “color” is listed as "Mulatto." William White, Nelson’s father, in contrast, is described as “White." The birth certificate is the only surviving source to describe Esther as "mulatto," a recognition that her father was of mixed racial ancestry himself, the son of an enslaved woman and a white enslaver. Esther must have been the informant on the birth certificate. It is thus possible that she defined herself as “mulatto” to the hospital administrator who filled out the paperwork and queried what to write in the “color” box on the birth certificate.[18] On the 1900 U.S. Census, Esther and her family were listed as “white,” while in 1910 they were defined as “Indian.”[19] Ritchie family descendants do demonstrate some Native American ancestry in their DNA, but a greater degree of African ancestry prevails. Nelson Holder Ritchie, Esther’s father, was variously defined in census reports and other records as “colored,” “Black,” or “mulatto,” before moving to Utah.[20] Esther, in contrast, apart from the 1910 census, is consistently listed as white.[21] Her son’s birth certificate is the sole surviving source to acknowledge her mixed racial ancestry.
Esther remained a practicing Latter-day Saint over the coming decade and must have set her sights on temple worship as a manifestation of her faith. Her mother and several of her siblings attended the temple in the 1920s and were “sealed” to their father by proxy following his death in 1913, this despite Latter-day Saint policies in place designed to prevent such rituals for people of Black African ancestry, even by proxy after death.[22] Esther attended the Salt Lake Temple on 4 November 1929 accompanied by her mother Annie. She received her washing and anointing and endowment rituals and was then sealed to her mother as well as to her father by proxy. She was also sealed to Orson Edwards, her deceased husband, by proxy on the same day.[23] There is no surviving hint of concern over Esther’s racial identity in 1929. Esther’s surviving parent was white and attended the temple with Esther, which no doubt helped to facilitate Esther’s racial passage. Esther also received her recommend to attend the temple from a different bishop than the one who had barred her father and mother in 1909. Her father was dead and the new bishop likely had no knowledge of his racial identity, all factors in her ability to receive the same temple rituals that had been denied her parents twenty years earlier.
Surviving sources do not indicate what the catalyst may have been, but the following decade was difficult for Esther. Her mental health deteriorated and by 1930 she was placed in the Salt Lake County Infirmary where she would stay for at least the next decade. The 1930 and 1940 federal census records list her among the patients at the infirmary as do Esther’s 1930 and 1935 Latter-day Saint censuses.[24] The County Infirmary, as it came to be called, was established in the 1880s at 2001 South State Street in Salt Lake City. It served as a hospital for the public at large as well as for the poor and mentally ill. By the time that Esther was housed there, the Infirmary had a 125-bed capacity and used electric shock therapy to treat some patients with mental illness.[25] There is no evidence that Esther received such treatment. Her medical records from the Infirmary do not survive, making it impossible to know.
Esther’s census records do however offer some insight into her mental state while a patient at the Infirmary. On the 1930 federal census Esther could not remember the birthplace of her mother and father. The census enumerator initially wrote “not known” in both boxes but then crossed out those words and scrawled “U.S.” in the boxes instead. It is perhaps an indication that Esther was struggling with basic recall or was confused by the encounter with the census enumerator.[26]
Her 1930 and 1935 Latter-day Saint census records list her membership in the Wells Ward and her address as “County Infirmary.”[27] The clerk who created Esther’s membership record for the Wells Ward must have asked her who had performed her baptism and confirmation. Esther remembered the year, 1899, correctly, but could not recall the exact date or who performed those rituals. The clerk wrote “Hyrum Smith ?” in the box labeled “Baptized by” and “Joseph F. Smith ?” in the box for “Confirmed by.” The question marks at the end of both men’s names indicate a level of skepticism on the part of the clerk.[28] Hyrum Smith was Joseph F. Smith’s father and was murdered in 1844 along with his brother Joseph Smith, the founder of the faith. Joseph F. Smith had a son who he named Hyrum Mack Smith, who is likely the person Esther had in mind. The younger Hyrum was ordained a Latter-day Saint apostle in 1901 and served in that capacity until he passed away in 1918. He would have been well known to Esther as a Church leader. Joseph F. Smith would have been an apostle in 1899, at the time of Esther’s baptism, but he and his son Hyrum did not perform her baptism and confirmation. Salt Lake City 17th Ward records created at the time the baptism took place make that clear.[29] The clerk could have verified Esther’s information from her prior membership records in previous Latter-day Saint congregations but failed to do so. The entries, nonetheless, offer a small glimpse into Esther’s mental capacity as she spent at least ten years at the County Infirmary.
There is no indication when Esther was released from the Infirmary. It is possible that she lived at least a decade or more on her own outside of the county institution after recovering and being released. She has yet to be located in the 1950 census so it is difficult to determine how long she may have stayed at the Infirmary. A 1948 news item in the Davis County Clipper at least suggests that she was no longer a permanent resident at the Infirmary by that point. The Clipper notes that “during the past week” Esther had visited her mother, Annie Ritchie, at the home of her sister, Grace, in Woods Cross.[30] A decade later a 1958 Salt Lake City directory locates Esther living at 23 West 300 North in Salt Lake City, where she rented an apartment.[31]
The following year, in January 1959, Esther and her niece, Stella Goodwin, made the news when they went shopping together. Stella drove her car and left Esther in the vehicle while she went inside a shoe repair store on 300 South in Salt Lake City. At some point Esther got out of the car to put a penny in the parking meter and then returned to the automobile. It is not clear if Stella left the car running, but she must have. Apparently, Esther bumped the gear shift and the car lurched in reverse and then jumped forward in the opposite direction, rolling over the curb into the parking meter. It then crashed into the glass window of the storefront where it came to a stop. Esther was uninjured but estimated damages totaled “$1,500 to the shop, $300 to the car, and $62 to the parking meter.”[32]
It is possible that Esther’s niece, Stella, drove that same car later that year when she again gave Esther a ride, but this time the accident turned tragic. Two days before Christmas in 1959, Stella and her husband, John Goodwin, picked up Esther, along with her Christmas gifts for her family, and drove along Beck Street into Davis County, north of Salt Lake City. They planned to deliver their presents to relatives in Bountiful and spend time with family celebrating the holiday. Stella drove the car as she and her husband and Aunt Esther made their way toward Bountiful. Suddenly the steering component on the car failed and Stella lost control of the vehicle. It “turned end over end two and one-half times and came to rest on its top.” Esther was thrown from the car and killed instantly. She was 68 years old.[33] John Goodwin was also ejected from the car and later died from his injuries. Stella, the driver, was the only one to survive.[34] It was a terrible tragedy which cast a pall over the Ritchie family’s Christmas celebrations that year.
Esther was a member of the Capitol Hill Ward by the time she died and was remembered as “Active in Singing Mothers and Relief Society,” the women’s organization in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Her son Nelson and daughter Florence survived her. She was laid to rest in Bountiful Memorial Park, in Bountiful, Utah, in 1959--the daughter of a formerly enslaved man who fought in the Civil War on the side of freedom.[35]
By W. Paul Reeve
[1] W. Paul Reeve, “Nelson Holder Ritchie,” Century of Black Mormons.
[2] John Mills Whitaker, Memorandum from the daily journal of John M. Whitaker (December 1906 to March 1912), typescript of transcripts from John M. Whitaker journal, 150, J. Willard Marriott Library, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah.
[3] Esther Ritchie (KWVZ-JXG), ordinance records at FamilySearch.org.
[4] Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Record of Members Collection, Iowa State (Part 2), Segment 1, Image 76, CR 375 8, Church History Library, Salt Lake City, Utah.
[5] Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Record of Members Collection, Iowa State (Part 2), Segment 1, Image 68, CR 375 8, Church History Library, Salt Lake City, Utah; William C. Mann, mission journal, MS 26229, 99-100, Church History Department, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Salt Lake City, Utah.
[6] “N. H. Ritchie,” Great Bend Tribune, 23 September 1892.
[7] Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Record of Members Collection, Sugar House Ward, CR 375 8, box 6743, folder 1, image 469, Church History Library, Salt Lake City, Utah.
[8] Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Record of Members Collection, Salt Lake 17th Ward (Part 1), CR 375 8, box 6378, folder 1, image 470, Church History Library, Salt Lake City, Utah.
[9] “Little Girl’s Wanderings,” Salt Lake Herald (Salt Lake City, Utah) 19 September 1899, 3.
[10] United States, 1900 Census, Utah, Salt Lake County, Salt Lake City; United States, 1910 Census, Utah, Salt Lake County, Sugar House.
[11] John Mills Whitaker, Memorandum from the daily journal of John M. Whitaker (December 1906 to March 1912), typescript of transcripts from John M. Whitaker journal, 150, J. Willard Marriott Library, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah.
[12] Utah, Salt Lake County, Marriages, Orson Edwards and Esther Ritchie, 6 April 1916, License No. 23734; “Marriage Licenses,” Salt Lake Herald (Salt Lake City, Utah) 7 April 1916, 6.
[13] Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Record of Members Collection, Wells Ward, microfilm 889,385, Family History Library, Salt Lake City, Utah.
[14] Utah, Salt Lake County, Death Record, Registered No. P-201, Orson Edwards, 19 January 1919.
[15] United States, 1920 Census, Utah, Salt Lake County, Salt Lake City.
[16] “Edwards, Esther Ritchie,” Presiding Bishopric stake and mission census, 1920 Census, Family History Library, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Salt Lake City, Utah.
[17] Utah, State Board of Health, Certificate of Birth, File No. 3117, Registered No. 2350, Nelson Edwards, 25 August 1921.
[18] Utah, State Board of Health, Certificate of Birth, File No. 3117, Registered No. 2350, Nelson Edwards, 25 August 1921.
[19] United States, 1900 Census, Utah, Salt Lake County, Salt Lake City, Third Precinct; United States, 1910 Census, Utah, Salt Lake County, Sugar House.
[20] W. Paul Reeve, “Nelson Holder Ritchie,” Century of Black Mormons.
[21] United States, 1920 Census, Utah, Salt Lake County, Salt Lake City; United States, 1930 Census, Utah, Salt Lake County, Salt Lake City; United States, 1940 Census, Utah, Salt Lake County, Salt Lake City.
[22] Devery S. Anderson, ed. The Development of LDS Temple Worship, 1846-2000: A Documentary History (Salt Lake City: Signature Books, 2011), 82, 101-2, 361.
[23] Esther Ritchie (KWVZ-JXG), ordinance records at FamilySearch.org.
[24] United States, 1930 Census, Utah, Salt Lake County, Salt Lake City; United States, 1940 Census, Utah, Salt Lake County, Salt Lake City; “Edwards, Esther Ritchie,” Presiding Bishopric stake and mission census, 1930 and 1935 Censuses, Family History Library, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Salt Lake City, Utah.
[25] Jeff Hatch and Larry Decker, “Salt Lake County Hospital History,” www.archives.slco.org.
[26] United States, 1930 Census, Utah, Salt Lake County, Salt Lake City.
[27] “Edwards, Esther Ritchie,” Presiding Bishopric stake and mission census, 1930 and 1935 Censuses, Family History Library, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Salt Lake City, Utah.
[28] Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Record of Members Collection, Wells Ward, microfilm 889,385, Family History Library, Salt Lake City, Utah.
[29] For the best biography on Joseph F. Smith, see Stephen C. Taysom, Like a Fiery Meteor: The Life of Joseph F. Smith (University of Utah Press, 2023); on Hyrum Smith see pages 14-16, 35-40, 43, 46; on Hyrum Mack Smith see 158, 204, 258, 262-68, 289-90, 294, 340, 350-51.
[30] Agness B. Mangus, “West Bountiful,” Davis County Clipper (Bountiful, Utah) 23 July 1948, 5.
[31] Polk’s Salt Lake City Suburban Directory, 1958 (R. L. Polk & Co., 1958), 302.
[32] “Backward, Forward—Oops, Crash, Bang!” Deseret News (Salt Lake City, Utah) 16 January 1959, 32.
[33] “Auto Upends on U.S. 91, Woman Dies,” Salt Lake Tribune (Salt Lake City, Utah) 24 December 1959, 9; “Utah Crash Kills Woman,” Daily Herald (Provo, Utah) 24 December 1959; “Utah Traffic Toll Goes to 198,” Herald Journal (Logan, Utah) 24 December 1959, 8; “S.L. Crash Victim Remains Critical at Hospital,” Salt Lake Tribune (Salt Lake City, Utah) 25 December 1959, 23.
[34] “Crash Injury Fatal for Utahn, 65,” Salt Lake Tribune, 27 December 1959, 19.
[35] “Ester Edwards,” Deseret News (Salt Lake City, Utah) 24 December 1959, B6; Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Record of Members Collection, Capitol Hill Ward (Part 2, Form E) CR 375 8, Church History Library, Salt Lake City, Utah; Utah, State Board of Health, Death Certificate, Registrar’s No. 2888, State File No. 59 18 2905, Esther Ritchie Edwards, 23 December 1959.
Documents
Click the index tab in the viewer above to view all primary source documents available for this person.

